Verdict
Depends — check the facts first
Contractual variants of this denial are final; factual-error variants are winnable. Run the checks on this page before spending the appeal window.
Winnable only with proof: an electronic acceptance report or certified-mail record showing timely original submission, a wrong-payer-first trail (COB confusion), or a state statutory floor the contract deadline violates. Without proof of timely filing, this denial usually stands — and the write-off cannot be billed to the patient under most participation agreements.